Sunday, September 19, 2010
Even the Little Guy Now Realizes that the Stock Market is Gamed, And Many Are Pulling Out Entirely
As I noted in January:
Joseph Stiglitz says that Wall Street is hyping up the economy to sell more stock.
Has it worked?
Well, the stock market certainly has rocketed up from its March lows.
But many investors are still avoiding equities.
As Vincent Deluard - a strategist for TrimTabs Investment Research (25% of the top 50 hedge funds in the world use TrimTabs' research for market timing) - says:
We've never seen this before – such a huge rally, and the little guy is out.In other words, the stock market rally is due almost entirely to hedgies, pension funds, banks and other institutional investors, and not every day investors.
It is even possible that the government itself has been propping up the stock market. And Bill Gross and Nouriel Roubini say that we have a Ponzi style economy.TrimTabs notes that small investors pulled out $14 billion net from stock mutual funds from the beginning of last year through mid-December, on top of a net $245 billion withdrawn in 2008.
Given that, at the end of September, individuals held 80% of the $19 trillion in stock in U.S. companies, both private and public - according to the Federal Reserve (see this, for example)- recovery will not happen so long as the little guys are sitting on the sidelines.
TrimTabs notes that most of $592 billion taken out of money market mutual funds last year has gone into bond and bond-hybrid funds instead.
The little guy has not gotten back in since then.
Indeed, AFP notes that high-frequency trading and other scams by the big boys has so obviously destroyed a level playing field that the little guy is getting out of the stock market entirely:
Michael McCaslin is wary of investing his retirement funds in Wall Street. Its volatility and cryptic trading techniques make him feel lost and unsafe, he says.
"I tried to watch the market over the past couple of years, and you're just lost. I look at the market now and it's like Las Vegas, it's a gamble," the 65-year-old pensioner said.
***
Yet the extreme instability that has characterized the markets since the 2008 financial meltdown, often blamed on highly speculative trading, and the increased use of super-fast automated trading systems make Wall Street a tough environment for small investors.
And as a result, more Americans have fled the stock market in recent months.
***"I don't have that ability, I am at the mercy of these people and with their automatic trading and the other things they can take advantage of, I don't know what can happen to the market because, you know, it can happen in milliseconds with the automatic trading," he said.
Often known as high frequency trading (HFT), the ultra-fast algorithms buy and sell millions of shares a day, executing deals within split seconds. They today account for more than 50 percent of daily trading volume.
HFT has come under increased scrutiny and criticism following the May 6 "Flash Crash" which saw market indexes dive by more than nine percent in minutes, only to rebound again after seconds.
The stock exchange's extreme volatility and complexity leaves average investors scared.
***Even savvy traders find it almost impossible to master the stock market as trading increasingly becomes dominated by machines and fractured by a myriad of highly specialized and often little-known markets called black pools.
"How can I compete with a computer system that can put in 200, 300 trading orders in a second?" asks Troy Hanninen, a professional individual investor who works from his home in Missoula, Montana.
If Hanninen wants to buy stock at 35 dollars a share, computers will get them a fraction of a second before him at 34.999 dollars, he says.
"Ever since the domination of the computers came out, you have many individual traders like me struggle because of the ability of high frequency traders to sub-penny us... that issue has driven liquidity from the market."
***
"Retail broker-dealers have told us that their customers -- individual investors -- have pulled back from participating in the equity markets since May 6," she said.The SEC's website has been flooded by letters from angry and frustrated investors in recent months.
"I recognize that there may be a variety of reasons for reduced participation in the equity markets, but the trend is troubling, particularly if concerns about equity market structure are playing even a small role in investor decision-making," [SEC head Mary] Schapiro said.
Tyler Durden - who has done more than anyone to expose high-frequency trading and related scams - has documented the recent outflows from the equities market in a series of essays. See for example this, this, this and this.
7 comments:
→ Thank you for contributing to the conversation by commenting. We try to read all of the comments (but don't always have the time).
→ If you write a long comment, please use paragraph breaks. Otherwise, no one will read it. Many people still won't read it, so shorter is usually better (but it's your choice).
→ The following types of comments will be deleted if we happen to see them:
-- Comments that criticize any class of people as a whole, especially when based on an attribute they don't have control over
-- Comments that explicitly call for violence
→ Because we do not read all of the comments, I am not responsible for any unlawful or distasteful comments.
Posts
The Wall Street investment bankers can masturbate their money 300/sec all they want. They are not getting any of my money. When the entire market is a half dozen computers trying to beat each other with higher transaction rates, maybe this scam will come to an end. Won't matter. It will be years or decades before anyone trusts it.
ReplyDeleteThe rules in this economy require businesses to spend most of their time placating government, looking for government bailout opportunities, -while- dodging-or-trying-to-catch the ever-presently-mutating-myriad-threat of regulatory catastrophe -and- windfall.
ReplyDeleteThank you, Alexander Hamilton.
EVEN IF the equity markets were legitimate, (and they aren't -and- never have been) -how could anyone bet on -what- the value of an inherently worthless stock share is worth day-in and day-out when the free market is as relevant as ancient Greece, -or- what the Druids were really up to at Stonehenge?
My wife said recently, it was definitely a guy's-hangout, -Stonehenge. She said -they had to have made jokes about the amount of time wasted there.
There is so very little in this world today that-has-value that is not taxed into a mocking -liability- that just owning -whatever- makes it an-anchor-without-a-ship.
"I don't know why I ever bought that," is a phrase we all have surrendered to this too often cursed infinitely complex reality.
One has no place to truly -invest- today.
And-that-reality is made doubly true in our deflationary environment that is being inexpertly honed and harassed by the purveyors of potential-hyperinflation.
Ben's current operating-theory, that he could and would will get the money back AFTER he threw it out of the helicopter, boggles the mind -in more ways than one.
It is all a gamble, and a sucker's bet for-sure.
Schopenhauer said it best. It (reality itself) is a lose-lose situation.
PUT YOUR MONEY, EFFORT AND TIME into maintaining your health.
That truism is often uttered, and too often the-important-ignored-advice -until it is far too late.
It does not get easier with age.
Maintaining your health has absolutely NOTHING to do with doctors or the medical industry.
That vile industry just plays on your weaknesses and fears, compounding these from the moment you walk in the door, until the day they finally kill you off with a handsome fee tied with a wire to your lifeless-right-toe lonesomely sticking out from underneath a bed-sheet.
Maintaining your health is about life-style choices; what you eat, what you do for a living and for leisure, where you choose to live, how far you might drive, and how much exercise you take.
Th Atkins Diet is a marketing fraud thought-up by the meat industry. People swear it works. But they all -also look a little bovine -if you ask me.
Salt is a quiet-killer worse than cigarettes, -they say now... Quit them both.
Your health is your wealth. It is so trite, and oh-so true.
And as a country, even as a world, we get less wealthy every day.
The latest round of pollution given to the Gulf of Mexico has made our end of the world massively less-wealthy.
I have NOT seen the recently-docile "trillions" moniker being attached to the Gulf of Mexico -yet-. And perhaps there's a reason for that.
What comes after a trillion? A gazillion?
wall street is more repugnant than a flaming bowel movement. I hope its destroyed by a giant jalapeno pepper!!
ReplyDeleteA few months ago as a novice and paranoid investor trying to make some small trades, I learned a hard lesson, lost my couple of thousand in a new york minute, too late to figure out that the HFTs were gaming the system. Never again! Unreal situation. These programs need to be banned. Stock trading needs to be limited to dividend producing stocks and bonds. Even so, the banksters will always find a way to rig it. Ever since Rothschild scammed the Brits after Waterloo...the stock market is a scam and we need to figure out a way to delink it as a measure of the health of the economy, because it should not be the barometer.
ReplyDeleteSurely this only applies to short-term investors?
ReplyDeleteIf you can get a good share price for a healthy company that pays a healthy dividend, you should do well in the long term.
"Tyler Durden - who has done more than anyone to expose high-frequency trading and related scams - has documented the recent outflows from the equities market in a series of essays."
ReplyDeleteI've also learned a lot from Max Keiser.
look to people to people lending for a different way of investing.
ReplyDeleteLending club
Prosper
These have worked for me.